• 1. 1989: The Best Four Years of My Life 4:20
• 2. Your New Favorite Song 2:36
• 3. Five Sexy Alligators, Please 2:31
• 4. Destination: Pizza 3:33
• 5. I'll Be Your Huckleberry 2:54
• 6. Houston, We Have a Drinking Problem 2:14
• 7. Chris, Did You Ruin the Dance Party 4:12
• 8. Saccharine for My Sweetie 3:27
• 9. Nominative Was the Case They Gave Me 2:55

Tracklisting from Last.fm