• 1. Belize Navidad (feat. Anika Pyle) 1:03
• 2. Christmas Guitar 2:53
• 3. I'm Not Ready for Christmas (feat. Mae Whitman) 3:38
• 4. Chris Farren's Disney's Frozen (feat. Anika Pyle & Sean Bonnette) 1:07
• 5. Waiting for You in the Snow (feat. Laura Stevenson) 3:03
• 6. Like a Gift from God or Whatever (feat. Jenny Owen Youngs) 2:37
• 7. Merry Christmas Again (feat. Jeff Rosenstock & Koji) 3:12
• 8. The Undertaker 3:21
• 9. Emo Revival Christmas 2014 4:20
• 10. Happier New Year (feat. Lee Corey Oswald) 3:48
• 11. Shelby's Christmas Eve 1:48
• 12. I Wish It Was Christmas Every Day (feat. Sean Bonnette, Allison Weiss & Jeff Rosenstock) 3:21

Tracklisting from Last.fm